Effects of Partial Replacement of Sodium Chloride by Potassium Chloride on Rheological, Sensory, Qualitative and Microbial Characteristics of Baguettes

Document Type : Review Article


1 Department of Food Science and Technology, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, I.R. IRAN

2 Research Department of Food Technology, National Nutrition and Food Technology Research Institute, Faculty of Nutrition Sciences and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, I.R. IRAN

3 Department of Food Sciences and Technology, National Nutrition and Food Technology Research Institute, Faculty of Nutrition Sciences and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Tehran, I.R. IRAN


The current study aimed to investigate the effects of partial replacement of sodium chloride by potassium chloride on baguettes' rheological, sensory, qualitative, and microbial characteristics. Replacement of sodium chloride by potassium chloride in null flour at 0% potassium chloride (control group, 100% sodium chloride), Treatment 1 (75% sodium chloride and 25% potassium chloride), Treatment 2 (50% sodium chloride and 50% potassium chloride), Treatment 3 (75% sodium chloride and 25% potassium chloride) and Treatment 4 (100% potassium chloride) was studied in baguettes. Results of the microbial count of flour showed that Treatment 2 included the highest yeast number of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Investigation of rheological characteristics of dough using farinograph and extensograph devices showed significant differences in experimental treatments (p ≤ 0.05) that Treatment 2 showed better conditions than other experimental treatments. Assessment of the sensory characteristics of baguettes demonstrated the efficacy of Treatment 2 in treatments and significant differences were observed in porosity, texture, and taste of bread (p ≤ 0.05). Therefore, it seems possible to produce bread with fewer levels of sodium chloride and partly substitute them with potassium chloride with no significant effects on the quality of bread. In conclusion, a replacement level of 50% potassium chloride with 50% sodium chloride is suggested to produce baguettes of good quality.


Main Subjects

[1] Jacob Arriola K.R., Ellis A., Webb-Girard A., Awino Ogutu E., McClintic E., Caruso B., Freeman M.C., Designing Integrated Interventions to Improve Nutrition and WASH Behaviors in Kenya, Pilot Feasibil. Stud., 6: 10–26 (2020).
[2] MacIntyre U.E., Kruger H.S., Venter C.S., Vorster H.H., Dietary intakes of an African Population in Different Stages of Transition in the North-West Province, South Africa: The THUSA Study, Nutr. Res., 22: 239–256 (2002).
[3] Charlton E.K., Mac Gregor E., Vorster H.N., Levitt S.N., Steyn K., Partial replacement of NaCl Can be Achieved with Potassium, Magnesium and Calcium Salts in Brown Bread, Int. J. Food Sci. Nutr., 58: 508–521 (2007).
[4] Quilez J., Salas-Salvado J., Salt in Bread in Europe: Potential Benefits of Reduction, Nutr. Rev., 70: 666-678 (2012).
[5] Belz M., Ryan L., Arendt E., The Impact of Salt Reduction in Bread: A Review, Crit. Rev. Food Sci. Nutr., 52: 514–524 (2012).
[6] Kloss L., Dawn Meyer J.D., Graeve L., Vetter W., Sodium Intake and Its Reduction by Food Reformulation in the European Union, NFS J., 1: 9-19 (2015).
[7] Anonymous, “Salt and Health: Review of the Scientific Evidence and Recommendations for Public Policy in Ireland”. The Report of Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI), 1–32 (2005).
[8] Vandevijvere S., Keyzer W.D., Chapelle J.P., Jeanne D., Mouillet G., Huybrechts I., Estimate of Total Salt Intake in Two Regions of Belgium Through Analysis of Sodium in 24-h Urine Samples, Euro. J. Clin. Nutr., 64: 1260–1265 (2010).
[9] Meneton P., Jeunemaitre X., De Wardener H.E., Macgregor G.A., Links between Dietary Salt Intake, Renal Salt Handling, Blood Pressure, and Cardiovascular Diseases, Physiol. Rev., 85: 679–715 (2005).
[10] Bates B., Lennox A., Prentice A., Bates C., Swanet G., “National Diet and Nutrition Survey”, Headline Results from Years 1, 2 and 3 (Combined) of the Rolling Programme (2008/2009 – 2010/11), 1–79 (2010).
[11] Ferrante D., Apro N., Ferreira V., Virgolini M., Aguilar V., Sosa M., Feasibility of Salt Reduction in Processed Foods in Argentina, PAHO Pan Am. J Public Health, 29: 69-75 (2011).
[12] Braschi A., Gill L., Naismith D.J., Partial Substitution with Potassium in White Bread: Feasibility and Bioavailability, Int. J. Food Sci. Nutr., 60: 507–521 (2009).
[13] Constantin M., Alexandru I., The Role of Sodium in the Body, Balneo-Res. J., 2: 70–74 (2011).
[14] Bassett M.N., Perez-Palacios T., Cipriano I., Cardoso P., Ferreira I., Samman N., Pinho O., Development of Bread with NaCl Reduction and Calcium Fortification: Study of its Quality Characteristics, J. Food Qual., 37: 107–116 (2014).
[15] Sayar S., Erdogdu F., Eydemir G., Nayman E., Partial Substitution of Sodium Chloride by Potassium Chloride in Bread: Effect on Dough and Bread Properties, Wageningen Academic Publishers, 8: 609 – 616 (2016).
[16] Gusmao T., Alexandre A., de Souza N., Sassi K., de Gusmao R., Moreira R., Partial Replacement of Sodium Chloride by Potassium Chloride in the Formulation of French Bread: Effect on the Physical, Physicochemical and Sensory Parameters, Food Sci. Technol., 37: 55–62 (2017).
[18] Mohamed A., Xu J., Singh M., Yeast Leavened Banana-Bread: Formulation, Processing, Colour and Texture Analysis, Food chem., 118: 620–626 (2010).
[19] AACC, “Approved Methods of the American   Association of Cereal Chemists”, 10a. Edition. Paul, Minnesota. Am. Assoc. Cereal Chemists (2000).
[20] Ebrahimpour N., Peghambardoust S.H., Azadmard Damirchi S., Ghanbarzadeh B., The Effect of Adding Different Hydrochloids on the Sensory and Staling Features of Gluten-Free Bread, J. Food Indust. Res., 20(3): 99–120 (2010).
[21] Movahed S., “The Science of Bread”, Marzedanesh Publishing, pp. 24–169 (2011).
[22] Rajabzadeh N., “Bread Technology”, Tehran University Press and Publishing, pp. 448 (2017).
[23] Najafian G., Bahraee S., Baghaee N., Morteza-Gholi M., Babaee-Goli E., “Bread Making Quality Attributes of Iranian Trade Cultivars of Wheat and their HMW Glutenin Subunits Composition”, In: Appels, R., Eastwood, R., Lagudah, E., Langridge, P., Mackay, M., Mcintgre, L. and P. Sharp (eds.), Proceedings of 11th International, Wheat Genetics Symposium, 24–29 Aug. 2008, Brisbane, QLD, Australia (2008).
[24] Egan H., Kirk R., Sawyer R., “Pearson's Chemical Analysis of Foods”, Edinburgh; Churchill Livingstone, pp. 591 (1981).
[25] Curik D., Karlovic D., Tusak D., Petrovic B., Dugum J., Gluten as a Standard of Wheat Flour Quality, Food Technol. Biotechnol., 39: 353–361 (2001).
[26] Ionescu V., Stoenescu G., Vasilean I., Aprodu I., Banu, I., Comparative Evaluation of Wet Gluten Quantity and Quality Through Different Method, Food Technol., 34: 44–48 (2010).
[27] Patwa A., Malcolm B., Wilson J., Ambrose, R.P.K., Particle Size Analysis of Two Distinct Classes of Wheat Flour by Sieving, Am. Soci. Agric. Biol. Eng., 57: 151–159 (2014).
[28] Sullivan B., Engebreston W.E., Anderson, M.L., The Relation of Particle Size of Certain Flour Characteristics, Cereal Chem., 37: 436–455 (1960).
[29] Debbouz A., Pitz W.J., Moore W.R., Dappolonia B.L., Effect of Bleaching on Durum-Wheat and Spaghetti Quality, Cereal Chem., 72: 128–131 (1995).
[30] Hatcher D.W., Anderson M.J., Desjardins R.G., Edwards N.M., Dexter J.E., Effects of Flour Particle Size and Starch Damage on Processing and Quality of White Salted Noodles, Cereal Chem., 79: 64–71 (2002).
[31] Lopes M., Cavaleiro C., Ramos F., Sodium Reduction in Bread: A Role for Glasswort (Salicorniaramosissima  iJ. Woods), Comp. Rev. Food Sci. Food Saf., 1: 1–16 (2017).
[33] Svec I., Hruskova M., Wheat Flour Fermentation Study, Czech J. Food Sci., 22: 17–23 (2004).
[34] Beck M., Jekle M., Becker T., Impact of Sodium Chloride on Wheat Flour Dough for Yeast-Leavened Products. I. Rheological Attributes, J. Sci. Food Agric., 92: 585–592 (2012).
[35] Mudalal S., Petracci M., Effect of Sodium Chloride Replacement with Potassium Chloride on Quality Traits of Bicarbonate-Marinated Turkey Breast Meat, Braz. J. Poult. Sci., 21(3): eRBCA-2019-0996 (2019).
[36] Nachtigall F., Andre Silva Vidal V., Pyarasani R., Domínguez R., Lorenzo J.M., Pollonio M., Santos L., Substitution Effects of NaCl by KCl and CaCl2 on Lipolysis of Salted Meat, Foods, 8: 595–615 (2019).
[37] Bidlas E., Lambert R.J.W., Comparing the Anitmicrobial Effectiveness of NaCl and KCl with a View to Salt/Sodium Replacement, Int. J. Food Microbiol., 124: 98–102 (2008).
[38] Silow C., Axel C., Zannini E., Arendt E.K., Current Status of Salt Reduction in Bread and Bakery Products: A Review, J. Cereal Sci., 72: 135–145 (2016).
[39] Graça C., Fradinho P., Sousa I., Raymundo A., Impact of Chlorella vulgaris on the Rheology of Wheat Flour Dough and Bread Texture, LWT – Food Sci. Technol., 89: 466–474 (2018).
[40] Kaur A., Bala R., Singh B., Rehal J., Effect of Replacement of Sodium Chloride with Mineral Salts on Rheological Characteristics of Wheat Flour, Am. J. Food Technol., 6: 674–684 (2011).
[41] Carcea M, Narducci V, Turfani V, Mellara F., A Comprehensive Study on the Influence of Sodium Chloride on the Technological Quality Parameters of Soft Wheat Dough, Foods, 9(7): 952 –969 (2020).
[42] Majzobi M., Roshan F., Farahnaki E., Saberi B., The Effect of Adding Wheat Starch Adjusted by the Thermal-Moisture Process on the Properties of Dough and Bulk Bread, J. Food Ind. Res., 32(3): 155–164 (2013).
[43] Hackenberg S., Verheyen C., Jekle M., Becker T., Effect of Mechanically Modified Wheat Flour on Dough Fermentation Properties and Bread Quality, Euro. Food Res. Technol., 243: 287–296 (2017).
[44] Lopes M., Cavaleiro C., Ramos F., Sodium Reduction in Bread: a Role for Glasswort (Salicorniaramosissima j. Woods), Compr. Rev. Food Sci. Food Saf., 16: 1056–1071 (2017).
[45] Chen G., Ehmke L., Sharma C., Miller, R., Faa P., Smith G., Li Y., Physicochemical Properties and Gluten Structures of Hard Wheat Flour Doughs as Affected by Salt, Food Chem., 275 (2018).
[46] Hosseini S.E., Ardestani F., Improving the Qualitative, Rheological and Sensory Properties of Spaghetti Using Null Flour and Gluten, Quart. J. New Food Technol., 3(9): 59–67 (2015).
[47] Menteş Ö., Bakkalbaşşi E., Ercan R., Effect of the Use of Ground Flaxseed on Quality and Chemical Composition of Bread. Food Sci. Technol. Int., 14(4): 299–306 (2008).
[48] Zhi Ying D., Ji Chun T., Hua Wen Z., Yong Xiang Z., Yan Ling L., Application of Farinograph Quality Number (FQN) in Evaluating Dough and Baking Qualities of Winter Wheat, Acta Botanica Sinica, 25: 673–680 (2005).
[49] Ktenioudaki A., Butler F., Gallagher E., Dough Characteristics of Irish Wheat Varieties. I. Rheological Properties and Prediction of Baking Volume, LWT – Food Sci. Technol., 44: 594–601 (2011).
[50] Vasyukova A.T., Kononenko M.M., Alekseev A.E., Moshkin A.V., Tikhonov D.A., Influence of Malt on the Intensity of the Enzymatic Processes, J. Crit. Rev., 7(7): 479-482 (2020).
[51] Tuhumury H., Studi P., Hasil T., Fakultas P., Pattimura P.U., The Effects of Salt on Bread: Technological Considerations for Reduced Salt Levels, AGRICA, 4(2): 134–141 (2018).
[52] Tanaka K., Furukawa K., Matsumot H., Effect of Acid and Salt on Farinogram and Extensigram of Dough, Cereal Chem., 44: 675 (1967).
[53] El-Taib H., Rizk I., Yousif E., Hassan A., Effect of Barley Flour on Wheat Bread Quality, Arab Univers. J. Agric. Sci., 26: 1109-1119 (2018).
[55] Lynch E.J., Dal Bello F., Sheehan E.M., Cashmank K.D., Arendt E.K., Fundamental Studies on the Reduction of Salt on Dough and Bread Characteristics, Food Res. Int., 42: 885–891 (2009).
[56] Menkinoska M., Blazheska T., Stamatovska V., Comparison of the Rheological Characteristics of Bio-Fortified Flour Obtained from Soft Wheat Varieties Treska and Radika, J. Agric. Plant Sci., 17(1): 111–118 (2019).
[57] Tronsmo K.M., Magnus E.M., Baardseth P., Schofield J.D., Aamodt A., Faergestad E.M., Comparison of Small and Large Deformation Rheological Properties of Wheat Dough and Gluten, Cereal Chem., 80: 587–595 (2003).
[59] Tiziana A., Carcea M., Viscoelastic Behavior of Wheat Dough With Salt and a Salt Substitute Studied by Means of GlutoPeak®, Cereal Chem., 97(2): 216 –225 (2020).
[60] Uthayakumaran S., Batey I.L., Day L., Wrigley C.W., Salt Reduction in Wheatbased Foods E Technical Challenges and Opportunities, Food Australia, 63: 137–140 (2011).
[61] Ruusunen M., Vainionpää J., Lyly M., Lähteenmäki L., Niemistö M., Ahvenainen R., Puolanne E., Reducing the Sodium Content In Meat Products: the Effect of the Formulation in Low-Sodium Ground Meat Patties, Meat sci., 69: 53–60 (2005).
[62] Cepanec K., Vugrinec S., Cvetkovic T., Ranilovic J., Potassium Chloride-Based Salt Substitutes: A Critical Review with a Focus on the Patent Literature, Compr. Rev. Food Sci. Food Saf., 16(5): 881–894 (2017).
[63] Turfani V., Narducci V., Durazzo A., Galli V., Carcea M., Technological, Nutritional and Functional Properties of Wheat Bread Enriched with Lentil or Carob Flours, LWT-Food Sci. Technol., 78: 361–366 (2017).
[64] Primo-Martın C., van de Pijpekamp A., vanVliet T., de Jongh H.H.J., Plijter J.J., Hamer R.J., The Role of the Gluten Network in the Crispness of Bread Crust, J. Cereal Sci., 43: 342–352 (2006).
[65] Czuchajowska Z., Pomeranz Y., Jeffers H.C., Water Activity and Moisture-Content of Dough And Bread, Cereal Chem., 66: 128–132 (1989).
[66] Skobranek H., B¨ackereitechnologie, “Handwerk und Technik”, 3rd ed., Hamburg, Germany (1998).
[68] Matz S.A., Cookie and Cracker Technology, 3rd Ed., “van Nostrand Reinhold”, New York (1992).
[69] Cardone G., D'Incecco P., Pagani M.A., Marti A., Sprouting Improves the Bread-Making Performance of Whole Wheat Flour (Triticum aestivum L.), J. Sci. Food Agric., 100(6): 2453 – 2459 (2020).
[70] Rezaiimofrad M.R., Rangraz Jeddi F., Haddad Kashani H., Azarbad Z., Assarian, A., Study of Sodium Bcarbonate and Sodium Chloride in Bakeries of Isfahan-Iran, Report Opin., 8: 78–82 (2016).
[72] Takano H., Kondou R., Sodium Gluconate and Potassium Gluconate as Substitutes for Sodium Chloride in Bread Making, Food Sci. Technol. Res., 8: 75–79 (2002).