Decentralized Advanced Model Predictive Controller of Fluidized-Bed for Polymerization Process

Document Type : Research Article


1 Department of Chemical Engineering, UiTM University of Mara, 40450 Shah Alam, MALAYSIA

2 Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Malaya, 50603 Kuala Lumpur, MALAYSIA

3 Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Al Ain, Al Ain, U.A.E.


The control of fluidized-bed operations processes is still one of the major areas of research due to the complexity of the process and the inherent nonlinearity and varying dynamics involved in its operation. There are varieties of problems in chemical engineering that can be formulated as NonLinear Programming (NLPs). The quality of the developed solution significantly affects the performance of such system. Controller design involves tuning the process controllers and implementing them to achieve certain performance of controlled variables by using Sequential Quadratic Programming (SQP) method to tackle the constrained high NLPs problem for modified mathematical model for gas phase olefin polymerization in fluidized-bed catalytic reactor.The objective of this work is to present a comparative study; PID control is compared to an advanced neural network based MPC decentralized controller and also, see the effect of SQP on the performance of controlled variables. The two control approached were evaluated for set point tracking and load rejection properties giving acceptable results.  


Main Subjects

[1] Ahmmed S. Ibrehem, Mohamed Azlan Hussain, Nayef Mohamed Ghasem, Mathematical Model and Advanced Control for Gas Phase Olefin Polymerization in Fluidized-Bed Catalytic Reactors, Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 16(1), p. 84 (2007).
[2] Helal A.M., Elnashaie S.S., Numerical Construction of Bifurcation Diagrams for Non-Linear Complex Reaction Networks in Catalytic Reactors, Computers & Chemical Engineering, 14(6), p. 691(1990).
[3] Antonio Flores-Tlacuahuac, Lorenz T. Biegler, A Robust and Efficient Mixed-integer Non-Linear Dynamic Optimization Approach for Simultaneous Design and Control, Computer Aided Chemical Engineering, 20(1), p. 67 (2005).
[4] Kiashemshaki A., Mostoufi N., Pourmahdian S, Sotudeh-GharebaghR., Two phase Modeling of a Gas Phase Polyethylene Fluidized Bed Reactor, Chemical Engineering Science, 61, p. 3997 (2006).
[5] Aswin N. Venkat, P. Vijaysai and Ravindra D. Gudi, Identification of Complex Nonlinear Processes Based on Fuzzy Decomposition of the Steady State Space, Electronic Journal of Biotechnology, 10(4), (2007).
[6] Baker B.D., Richards C.E.,, Exploratory Application of Systems Dynamics Modeling to School Finance Policy, Journal of Education Finance, 27(3), p. 857 (2002).
[7] Biegler L., Improved Infeasible Path Optimizer for Sequential Modular Simulators-I: The Interface, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 9(3), p. 245 (1985).
[8] Bassam Alhamad, Jose A. Romagnoli, Vincent G. Gomes, On-Line Multi-Variable Predictive Control of Molar Mass and Particle Size Distributions in Free-Radical Emulsion Copolymerization, Chemical Engineering Science, 60(23), p. 6596 (2005).
[9] Babatunde A. Ogunnaike, Kapil Mukati, An Alternative Structure for Next Generation Regulatory Controllers : Part I: Basic Theory for Design, Development and Implementation, Journal of Process Control, 16(5), p. 499 (2006).
[10] Chatzidoukas C., Perkins J.D., Pistikopoulos E.N., Kiparissides C., Optimal-Grade Ransition and Selection of Closed-Loop Controllers in a Gas-Phase Olefin Polymerization Fluidized Bed Reactor, Chemical Engineering Science, 58, p. 3643 (2003).
[11] Chiaki Kuroda, Jinyoung Kim, Neural Network Modeling of Temperature Behavior in an Exothermic Polymerization Process, Neurocomputing, 43(1-4), p. 77 (2002).
[12] Charles D., Francis J. Doyle, Modeling of Particle Size Distribution in Emulsion co-Polymerization: Comparison with Experimental Data and Parametric Sensitivity Studies, Computers & Chemical Engineering, 26(7-8), p. 1133 (2002).
[13] Ang D.D., Pham Ngoc Dinh A., Thanh D.N., Regularization of an Inverse Two-Phase Stefan Problem, 34(5), p. 719 (1998).
[14] Dennis Van Hessem, Okko Bosgra, Stochastic Closed-Loop Model Predictive Control of Continuous Nonlinear Chemical Processes, Journal of Process Control, 16(3), p. 225 (2006).
[15] Del Vecchio D., Petit N., Boundary Control for An Industrial Under-Actuated Tubular Chemical Reactor, Ournal of Process Control, 15(7), p. 771 (2005).
[16] Dulce C.M. Silva, Nuno M.C. Oliveira, Optimization and Nonlinear Model Predictive Control of Batch Polymerization Systems, Computers & Chemical Engineering, 26(4-5), p. 649 (2002).
[17] Baker E.L., “Modeling and Optimization of Shaped Charge Liner Collapse and Jet Formation”, Ph.D. Dissertation, Washington State University, Pullman, Washington, (1992).
[18] Fine T.L., “Feed Forward Neural Network Methodology”, Springer, New York (1999).
[19] Francis J. Doyle, III , Christopher A. Harrison, Timothy J. Crowley, Hybrid Model-Based Approach to Batch-to-Batch Control of Particle Size Distribution in Emulsion Polymerization, Computers & Chemical Engineering, 27(8-9), p. 1153 (2003).
[20] Mourue G., Dochain D., Wertz V., Descamps P.,Identification and Control of An Industrial Polymerisation Reactor, Control Engineering Practice, 12(7), p. 909 (2004).
[21] Gangadhar Gattu Evanghelos Zafiriou, A Methodology for on-Line Setpoint Modification for Batch Reactor Control in the Presence of Modeling Error, Chemical Engineering Journal, 75(1), p. 21 (1999).
[22] Ravi Sriniwas G., Arkun Y., Joseph Schork F., Estimation and Control of an α-Olefin Polymerization Reactor, Ournal of Process Control, 5(5), p. 303 (1995).
[23] Hatzantonis H., Yiannoulakis H., Yiagopoulos A., Kiparissides C., Recent Developments in Modeling Gas-Phase Catalyst Olefin Polymerization Fluidized Bed Reactor: The Effect of Bubble Size Variation on the Reactor’s Performance, Chemical Engineering Science, 5, p. 3237 (2000).
[24] Huang B., Mujumdar A.S., Use of Neural Network to Predict Industrial Dryer Performance, Drying Technology, 3, p. 525 (1993).
[25] Hiroya Seki, Morimasa Ogawa, Satoshi Ooyama, Kouji Akamatsu, Masahiro Ohshima, Wang Yang, Industrial Application of a Nonlinear Model Predictive Control to Polymerization Reactors, Control Engineering Practice, 9(8), p. 819 (2001).
[26] Joachim Horn, Trajectory Tracking of a Batch Polymerization Reactor Based on Input-Output-Linearization of a Neural Process Model, Computers & Chemical Engineering, 25(11-12), p. 1561 (2001).
[27] Joaquim A., Dente R., Vilela mendes, Characteristic Functions and Process Identification by Neural Networks, Neural Networks, 10, p. 1465 (1997).
[28] Jesus Flores-Cerrillo, John F. MacGregor, Latent Variable MPC for Trajectory Tracking in Batch Processes, Journal of Process Control, 15(6), p. 651 (2005).
[29] Choi K.Y., Ray W.H., The Dynamic Behaviour of Fluidized Bed Reactors for Solid Catalyzed Gas Phase Olefin Polymerization, Chem. Eng. Sci., 40, p. 2261 (1985).
[30] Kenneth R. Harris, Ahmet Palazolu, Control of Nonlinear Processes Using Functional Expansion Models, Computers & Chemical Engineering, 27(8-9), p. 1061 (2003).
[31] Mc Auley Tousain, R.L.   Bosgra, O.H., Efficient Dynamic Optimization for Nonlinear Model Predictive Control-Application to a High-Density Poly-Ethylene Grade Change Problem, Decision and Control, "Proceedings of the 39th IEEE Conference", Vol. 1, pp. 760-765 (2000).
[32] Powell M.J.D., in “Numerical Analysis, Proceedings of the Biennial Conference Held at Dundee”, G.A. Watson eds., Lecture Notes in Mathematics, Vol. 630, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, New York, 1978, p. 144 (1977).
[33] Bazaraa M.S., Sherali H.D., Shetty C.M., “Nonlinear Programming:Theory and Algorithms”, 2nd edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, (1993).
[34] Hussain M.A., Shafiur Rahman M., Ng C.W., Prediction of Pores Formation (Porosity) in Foods During Drying: Generic Models by the Use of Hybrid Neural Network, Journal of Food Engineering, 51(3), p. 239 (2002).
[35] Mourad M., Hémati M., LaguérieMing C., Drying of Maize in a Fluidized Bed: II: A Kinetic, Model,of, Drying, Chemical Engineering Journal and the Biochemical Engineering Journal, 60, p. 39 (1995).
[36] Morimasa Ogawa, Masahiro Ohshima, Koji Morinaga, Fuminao Watanabe, Quality Inferential Control of an Industrial High Density Polyethylene Process, Journal of Process Control, 9(1), p. 51 (1999).
[37] Mourad M., He´ mati M., Lague´ rieMing C., Drying of Maize in a Fluidized Bed: II: a Kinetic Model of Drying, The Chemical Engineering Journal and the Biochemical Engineering Journal, 60 (1–3, 12), p. 39  (1995).
[38] Mariano Asteasuain, Alberto Bandoni, Claudia Sarmoria, Adriana Brandolin,Simultaneous Process and Control System Design for Grade Transition in Styrene Polymerization, Chemical Engineering Science, 61(10), p. 3362 (2006).
[39] Mahmood Alizadeh, Navid Mostoufi, Saeed Pourmahdian, Rahmat Sotudeh-Gharebagh, Modeling of Fluidized Bed Reactor of Ethylene Polymerization, Chemical Engineering Journal, 97, p. 27 (2004).
[40] Nayef Mohamed Ghasem, Mohd Zaki Sulaiman and Mohd Azlan Hussain, Simulation, Optimization and Parametric Studies of a Solid Catalyzed Gas Phase Ethylene Polymerization Fluidized Bed Reactor, Journal of Chemical Eng. of Japan, 38 p. 171 (2005).
[41] Abel O., Helbig A., Marquardt W., Zwick H., Daszkowski T., Productivity Optimization of An Industrial Semi-Batch Polymerization Reactor Under Safety Constraints, Journal of Process Control, 10(4), p. 351 (2000).
[42] Patwardhan R., Lakshminaraynan S., Shah S., Constrained nonlinear MPC Using Hammerstein and Wiener Models: PLS framework, AICHE Journal, 44(7), p. 1611 (1998).
[43] Gill P.E., Murry W., Wright M.H., “Practical Optimization”, Academic Press, New York, 1981.
[44] Evanghelos Zafiriou and Hung-Wen Chiou, On the Effect of Constrint Softening on the Stability and Performance of Model Predictive Controllers, AIChE, 1, p. 6 (1992).
[45] Roos. Sala, F. Valz-Gris and L. Zanderighi, A Fluid-Dynamic Study of a Continuous Polymerisation Reactor, Chemical Engineering Science, 29, p. 2205 (1974).
[46] Reddy B.V., Nag P.K., Axial and Radial Heat Transfer Studies in a Circulating Fluidized Bed, International Journal of Energy Research, 21, p. 1109 (1997).
[47] Rao C.V., Wright S.J., Rawlings J.B., Application of Interior-Point Methods to Model Predictive Control, Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications, 99(3), p. 723 (1998).
[48] Sala R., Valz-Gris F., Zanderighi L., A Fluid-Dynamic Study of a Continuous Polymerisation Reactor, Chemical Engineering Science, 29, p. 2205 (1974).
[49] Zeman R.J., Amundson N.R., Continuous Polymerization Models-Part II : Batch Reactor Polymerization, Chemical Engineering Science, 20, p. 637 (1965).
[50] Roberto Lemoine-Nava, Antonio Flores-Tlacuahuac, Enrique Sald´ıvar-Guerra,Non-linear Bifurcation Analysis of the Living Nitroxide-Mediated Radical Polymerization of Styrene in a CSTR, Chemical Engineering Science, 61(2), p. 370 (2006).
[51] Shaw A.M., Doyle F.J., Schwaber J.S., A Dynamic Neural Network Approach to Nonlinear Process Modeling, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 21, p. 371 (1997).
[52] Smith M., "Neural Networks for Statistical Modeling", International Thomson Computer Press, Boston (1996).
[53] Sablani S.S., A Neural Network Approach for Non-Iterative Calculation of Heat Transfer Coefficient in Fluid-Particle Systems, Chem. Eng. Process., 40,
p. 363 (2001).
[54] Shahaf G., Marom S., Learning in Networks of Cortical Neurons, Journal of Neuroscience, 21, p. 8782 (2001).
[55] Shaw A.M., Doyle F.J., Schwaber J.S l., A Dynamic Neural Network Approach to Nonlinear Process Modeling, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 21, p. 371 (1997).
[56] Sit S.P., Grace J.R., Effect of Bubble Interaction on Interphase Mass Transfer in Gas Fluidized Beds, Chemical Engineering Science, 36, p. 327 (1981).
[57] Smith, "Neural Networks for Statistical Modeling", International Thomson Computer Press, Boston,
[58] Sreekanth S.S., Ramaswamy H.S., Sablani S.S., Prasher S.O., A Neural Network Approach for Evaluation of Surface Heat Transfer Coefficient, Journal of Food Processing and Preservation, 23(4), p. 329 (1999).
[59] Sang, Hyun, Neural Network Modeling of Temperature Behavior in An Exothermic Polymerization Process, Neurocomputing, 43(1-4), p. 77 (2002).
[60] Simant R. Upreti, Baranitharan S. Sundaram, Ali Lohi, Optimal Control Determination of MMA Polymerization in Non-Isothermal Batch Reactor Using Bifunctional Initiator, European Polymer Journal, 41(12), p. 2893 (2005).
[61] Thomas, Francis, An Anti-Windup Scheme for Multivariable Nonlinear Systems, Journal of Process Control, 14(8), p. 899 (2004).
[62] Tarmy B.I., Coulaloglou, Industrial View of Gas/Liquid/Solid Reactor Development, Chemical Engineering Science, 47, p. 3231 (1992).
[63] Stephen Whitaker, "Handbook of Heat and Mass Transfer", vol.3, Catalyst, Kinetics, and Reactor Engineering, Ch. 26, p. 1061 (1989).
[64] Tabis B., Essekkat A., Three-Phase Multi-Compartment Model for Fluidized-Bed Catalytic Reactor. Autothermicity and Multiplicity of Steady States, Chem.Eng.Sci., 47(2), p. 407 (1992).
[65] Toomey R.D., Johnstone, Gaseous Fluidization of Solid Particles, Chemical Engineering Progress, 48,
p. 220 (1952).
[66] Wolf J.A., Moyer J.T., Lazarewicz M.T., Contreras D., Benoit-Marand M., O'Donnell P., Finkel L.H., Neuron or Other Electrically Excitable Cell, Physical Science Journal, 1(3), p. 13 (2005).
[67] Wei, Danial, "Control Relevant Model Reduction of Voltra Series Models, Department of Chemical, Bio and Materials Engineering and Control Systems Engineering", Arizona State University, USA, (1997).
[68] Werther, Modeling and Scale-Up of Industrial Fluidized Bed Reactors, Chemical Engineering Science, 35(1-2), p. 3 (1983).
[69] Xie, Edwards Allen, Noah Fahlgren, Adam Calamar, Scott A. Givan, James C. Carrington, Expression of Arabidopsis MIRNA Genes, American Society of Plant Biologists, 138, p. 2145 (2005).
[70] Xuejing Zheng, Makarand S. Pimplapure, Günter Weickert, Joachim Loos, Study the Porosity Effects of Ziegler Natta Catalyst on Polymerization System, European polymer journal, 68, p. 680 (2006).
[71] Xie T.T., McAuley K.B., Hsu J.C.C., Bacon D.W., Gas Phase Ethylene Modeling, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 33, p. 449 (1994).
[72] Zabrodsky S.S., “Hydrodynamics and Heat Transfer in Fluidized Beds”. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, U.S.A (1966).
[73] Ye Y., “Interior Point Algorithms for Quadratic Programming”, Paper Series No. 89-29, Dept. of Management Sciences, University of Iowa, Iowa City, (1988).
[74] Victor M. Zavala, Antonio Flores-Tlacuahuac and Eduardo Vivaldo-Lima, Dynamic optimization of a Semi-Batch Reactor for Polyurethane Production, Chemical Engineering Science, 60, p. 3061 (2005).
[75] Zeybek Z., Yüce S., Hapolu H., Alpbaz M., Adaptive Heuristic Temperature Control of a Batch Polymerisation Reactor, Chemical Engineering and Processing, 43(7), p. 911 (2004).
[76] Vieira R.A.M., Embiruçu M., Sayer C., Pinto J.C., Lima E.L., Control Strategies for Complex Chemical Processes. Applications in Polymerization Processes, Computers & Chemical Engineering, 27(8-9), p. 1307 (2003).
[77] Zhihua Xiong, Jie Zhang, Modelling and Optimal Control of Fed-Batch Processes Using a Novel Control Affine Feed Forward Neural Network, Neurocomputing, 61, p. 317 (2004).
[78] Yuan Tian, Jie Zhang, Julian Morris, Optimal Control of a Batch Emulsion Copolymerisation Reactor Based on Recurrent Neural Network Models, Chemical Engineering and Processing, 41(6), p. 531 (2002).
[79] Yaohui [Reference to Lu], Yaman, Quasi-Min-Max MPC Algorithms for LPV Systems, Automatica, 36(4), p. 527 (2000).