Study of Heat Exchanger Network Cleaning Schedule Design with Heuristic Scenario Analysis

Document Type : Research Article


1 Chemical Engineering Department, Mulawarman University, Samarinda, INDONESIA

2 Chemical Engineering Department, Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember, Surabaya, INDONESIA

3 Engineering Physics Department, Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember, Surabaya, INDONESIA

4 Chemical Engineering Department, National Cheng Kung University, Tainan, TAIWAN

5 Chemical Engineering Department, National Chung Hsing University, Taichung, TAIWAN


The crude oil refinery heat exchanger network (HEN) cleaning schedule is critical to maximize energy recovery and simultaneously maintain HEN performance. In reality, the HEN configuration consists of multiple heat exchanger units with different sizes, fouling rates, and initial efficiencies. The plant availability and the HEN efficiency may decrease to a certain level after a period of operation due to fouling and heat exchangers taken offline for cleaning. Therefore, the cleaning and bypass procedure is deemed necessary. In this study, the heat exchanger performance represented by the overall heat transfer coefficient is evaluated based on a proposed heuristics algorithm for seeking the optimum cleaning schedule while incorporating rigorous cleaning rules. Four heuristic values for HEN cleaning schedule scenarios are proposed to evaluate the overall performance of the HEN. The additional heat duty on the process heater due to cleaning operation and the total annual cost are considered in a crude oil refinery HEN that consists of 11 heat exchanger units. The cleaning frequency of the heat exchanger is found to have a significant effect on HEN performance. The results from the scenario analysis suggest that there is a proper cleaning schedule for the optimum operation of a crude oil refinery HEN. It is also indicated that
the design of the cleaning schedule depends on fouling resistance and the capacity of related heat exchangers.    


Main Subjects

[1] Panchal C. B., Huangfu E., Effects of Mitigating Fouling on the Energy Efficiency of Crude-Oil Distillation, Heat Transfer Eng., 21(3): 3–9 (2000).
[2] Macchietto S., Hewitt G.F., Coletti F., Crittenden B.D., Dugwell D.R., Galindo A., Jackson G., Kandiyoti R., Kazarian S.G., Luckham P.F., Matar O.K., Millan-Agorio M., Müller E.A., Paterson W., Pugh S.J., Richardson S.M.,  Wilson D.I., Fouling in Crude Oil Preheat Trains: A Systematic Solution to an Old Problem, Heat Transfer Eng., 32(3–4): 197–215 (2011).
[3] Epstein N., Thinking About Teat Transfer Fouling: A 5 × 5 Matrix, Heat Transfer Eng., 4(1): 43–56 (1983).
[4] Coletti F., Joshi H.M., Macchietto S., Hewitt, G.F., "Crude Oil Fouling: Deposit Characterization, Measurements, and Modeling", Elsevier Inc. (2015).
[5] Elsholkami M., Bajwa M., Aydemir M., Brown T., Elkamel A., Madhuranthakam C.M., "Optimizing Cleaning Schedules of Heat Exchanger Networks",  Proceedings of the 2016 International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management Detroit, Michigan, USA (2016).
[6] Awad M.M., Influence of Surface Temperature on Surface Fouling-Theoretical Approach, Life Sci. J., 9(3): 1733–1741 (2012).
[7] Kern D.Q., Seaton R.E., A Theoretical Analysis of Thermal Surface Fouling, Br. Chem. Eng., 4(5): 258–262 (1959).
[8] Bott T.R., "Fouling of Heat Exchangers", Elsevier Science & Technology Books, Amsterdam (1995).
[9] Wilson D.I., Ishiyama E.M., Polley G.T., Twenty Years of Ebert and Panchal—What Next?, Heat Transfer Eng., 38(7–8): 669–680 (2017).
[11] Sanaye S., Niroomand B., Simulation of Heat Exchanger Network (HEN) and Planning The Optimum Cleaning Schedule, Energy Convers. Manage., 48(5): 1450–1461 (2007).
[12] Ishiyama E.M., Heins A.V., Paterson W.R., Spinelli  L., Wilson D.I., Scheduling Cleaning in a Crude Oil Preheat Train Subject to Fouling: Incorporating Desalter Control, Appl. Therm. Eng., 30(13): 1852–1862 (2010).
[13] Rodriguez C., Smith R., Optimization of Operating Conditions for Mitigating Fouling in Heat Exchanger Networks, Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 85(6): 839–851, (2007).
[14] Jin Z., Chen, X., Dong Q., Liu M., Planning the Optimum Cleaning Schedule Based on Simulation of Heat Exchangers Under Fouling, Heat Transfer - Asian Research., 41(1): 33–42 (2012).
[15] Liu L.L., Fan J., Chen P.P., Du J., Yang F.L., Synthesis of Heat Exchanger Networks Considering Fouling, Aging, and Cleaning, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 54(1): 296–306 (2015).
[16] Georgiadis M.C., Papageorgiou L.G., Optimal Energy and Cleaning Management in Heat Exchanger Networks Under Fouling, Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 78(2): 168–179 (2000).
[17] Smaïli F., Vassiliadis V.S., Wilson D.I., Mitigation of Fouling in Refinery Heat Exchanger Networks by Optimal Management of Cleaning, Energy Fuels, 15(5): 1038–1056 (2001).
[18] Licindo D., Handogo R., Sutikno J.P., Optimization on Scheduling for Cleaning Heat Exchangers in the Heat Exchanger Networks, Chemical Engineering Transactions, 45: 835–840 (2015).
[19] Diaby A.L., Miklavcic S.J., Addai-Mensah J., Optimization of Scheduled Cleaning of Fouled Heat Exchanger Network Under Ageing Using Genetic Algorithm, Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 113: 223–240 (2016).
[20] Riham A.I., Min W. L., Wilson D. I., Vassilios S.V., Optimisation of Heat Exchanger Network Cleaning Schedules: Incorporating Uncertainty in Fouling and Cleaning Model Parameters, Comput. Chem. Eng., 121: 409–421 (2019).
[21] Santamaria L.F., Macchietto S., Integration of Optimal Cleaning Scheduling and Control of Heat Exchanger Networks Undergoing Fouling: Model and Formulation, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 57(38): 12842–12860 (2018).
[22] Riham A.I., Min W.L., Wilson D.I., Vassilios, S.V., Heat Exchanger Network Cleaning Scheduling: From Optimal Control to Mixed-Integer Decision Making, Comput. Chem. Eng., 111: 1–15 (2018).
[24] Smaïli F., Vassiliadis, V.S., Wilson D.I., Optimization of Cleaning Schedules in Heat Exchanger Networks Subject to Fouling, Chem. Eng. Commun., 189(11): 1517–1549 (2002).
[25] Lavaja J. H., Bagajewicz M.J., On a New MILP Model for the Planning of Heat-Exchanger Network Cleaning, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 43(14): 3924–3938 (2004).
[26] Gonçalves C.D.O., Queiroz E.M., Pessoa F.L.P., Liporace F.S., Oliveira S.G., Costa A.L.H., Heuristic Optimization of the Cleaning Schedule of Crude Preheat Trains, Appl. Therm. Eng., 73(1): 3–14 (2014).
[27] Biyanto T.R., Ramasamy M., Jameran A.B., Fibrianto H.Y., Thermal and Hydraulic Impacts Consideration in Refinery Crude Preheat Train Cleaning Scheduling Using Recent Stochastic Optimization Methods, Appl. Therm. Eng., 108: 1436-1450 (2016).
[28] Ebert W., Panchal C.B., Analysis of Exxon Crude Oil-Slip-Stream Coking Data, Fouling Mitigation Ind. Heat-Exch. Equip., Proc.", Int. Conf., 451–460 (1995).
[29] Polley G.T., Wilson D.I., Yeap B.L., Pugh S.J., Evaluation of Laboratory Crude Oil Threshold Fouling Data for Application to Refinery Pre-heat Trains, Appl. Therm. Eng., 22(7): 777–788 (2002).
[30] Biyanto T.R., Khairansyah M.D., Bayuaji R., Firmanto H., Haksoro T., Imperialist Competitive Algorithm (ICA) for Heat Exchanger Network (HEN) Cleaning Schedule Optimization, Procedia Computer Science., 72: 5–12 (2015).
[31] Hughes-Hallett D., "Calculus Single Variable", 7th ed. John Wiley & Sons, Inc, New York (2017).
[32] Zhang H., Cui G., Optimal Heat Exchanger Network Synthesis Based on Improved Cuckoo Search via Lévy Flights, Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 134: 62–79 (2018).
[37] Peters M.S., Timmerhaus K.D., West, E.R., "Plant Design and Economics for Chemical Engineers", 5th ed. McGraw-Hill Education, New York (2003).