Computer Simulation of Particle Size Classification in Air Separators

Document Type: Research Article


1 Faculty of Mining, Metallurgical and Petroleum Engineering, Amirkabir University of Technology, P.O.Box 1591634311, Tehran, I.R. IRAN

2 Department of Mining, Faculty of Engineering, University of Kashan, P.O.Box 8731751167, Kashan, I.R. IRAN


Cement powder size classification efficiency significantly affects quality of final product and extent of energy consumption in clinker grinding circuits. Static and dynamic or high efficiency air separators are being used widely in closed circuit with multi-compartment tube ball mills, High Pressure Grinding Rolls (HPGR) and more recently Vertical Roller Mills (VRM) units in cement plants to classify comminuted clinker particles at finish grinding stage. Therefore, simulation of air separators is of critical importance in order to provide tools that can assist cement plants engineers in their routine clinker grinding circuit optimization efforts. In this paper, Air Separator Simulator (ASSIM), a newly developed simulator implemented in VB™ which provides a user-friendly process analysis and optimization environment will be introduced. First, a review of mathematical modeling of cyclone separators is presented. Then, the details of ASSIM and the results of its testing using industrial data from J. K. White Cement Works plant will be discussed. The simulator is mainly based on the Whiten function to model air separators and predicts fine and coarse output streams particle size distributions and flow rates. ASSIM performance was verified and validated by comparing its outputs with measured data collected around an operating air separator. Preliminary software tests indicate the accuracy and precision of the developed code in predicting various properties of output streams as sum of least squares between predicted results and actual data is less than 0.01.  


Main Subjects

[1] Jankovic, A., Valery, W. and Davis, E., Cement Grinding Optimisation, Minerals Engineering, 17, p. 1075 (2004).

[2] Farzanegan, A., Laplante, A.R. and Lowther, D.A., A Knowledge-based System for an Off-Line Optimization of Ball Milling Circuits, Proceedings of 29th CMP Conference, Ottawa, 165-185 (1997).

[3] Farzanegan, A., Knowledge-Based Optimization of Mineral Grinding Circuits, Ph.D. Thesis, McGill University, Montreal, Canada (1998).

[4] Irannajad, M., Farzanegan, A. and Razavian, S.M.,  Spreadsheet-based Simulation of Closed Ball Milling Circuits, Minerals Engineering, 19, 1495 (2006).

[5] Zhang, Y.M., Napier-Munn, T.J. and Kavetsky, A., Application of Comminution and Classification Modelling to Grinding of Cement Clinker,
Trans. Inst. Min. Metall., Sect. C, 97, p. 207 (1988).

[6] Benzer, H., Ergün, L., Öner, M. and Lynch, A.J., Simulation of Open Circuit Clinker Grinding.  Minerals Engineering, 14 (7), p. 701 (2001a).

[7] Benzer, H., Ergün L., Lynch, A.J., Öner, M., Günlü, A., Çelik, I.B. and Aydoğan, N.,  Modeling Cement Grinding Circuits, Minerals Enginering, 14 (11), p. 1469 (2001b).

[8] Benzer, H.,  Modeling and Simulation of a Fully Air Swept Ball Mill in a Raw Material Grinding Circuit, Power Technology, 150, p. 145 (2004).

[9] Yadegar, Sh. and Pishvai, M.R., Mixed Qualitative / Quantitative Dynamic Simulation of Processing Systems, Iranian Journal of Chemistry & Chemical Engineering, 24, p. 53 (2005).

[10] Kolacz, J., Investigating Flow Conditions in Dynamic Air Classification, Minerals Engineering, 15, p. 131 (2002).

[11] Karunakumari, L. et al., Experimental and Numerical Study of a Rotating Wheel Air Classifier, AIChE  Journal, 5, p. 776 (2005).

[12] Griffiths W. and Boysan, F., Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) and Empirical Modelling of the Performance of a Number of Cyclone Separators, Journal of Aerosol Science, 27, p.  281 (1996).

[13] Wang,  Q.,  Melaaen,  M.C.  and  De  Silva,  S.R., Investigation and Simulation of a Cross-Flow Air Classifier, Powder Technology, 22, p. 273 (2001).

[14] Bakker,  A., Haidari,  A.H. and  Oshinowo, L.M., Realize Greater Benefits from CFD, AIChE Journal, 47, p.  45 (2001).

[15] Gorji  et al., CFD  Modeling  of Gas - Liquid Hydrodynamics in a Stirred Tank Reactor, Iranian Journal of Chemistry & Chemical Engineering, 42, p. 85 (2007).

[16] Nageswararao, K.,  Wiseman,  D.M.  and  Napier-Munn, T.J., Two Empirical Hydrocyclone Models Revisited, Minerals Engineering,17, p. 671 (2004).

[17] Napier-Munn, T.J., Morrell, S., Morrison, R.D. and Kojovic, T., “Mineral Comminution Circuits:
Their Operation and Optimization”, JKMRC, The University of Queensland (1999).

[18] Plitt, L.R., The Analysis of Solid-Solid Separations in Classifiers, CIM Bulletin, 64, p. 42 (1971).

[19] Finch, J.A., Modelling a Fish-Hook in Hydrocyclone Selectivity Curves, Powder Technology, 36, p. 128 (1983).

[20] Del Villar, R. and Finch, J.A.,  Modelling the Cyclone Performance with a Size Dependent Entrainment Factor, Minerals Engineering, 5 (6), p. 661 (1992).

[21]  Frachon, M. and  Cilliers, J. J.,  A  General Model for Hydrocyclone Partition Curves, Chemical Engineering Journal, 73, p. 53 (1999).

[22] Nageswararao K.,  A Critical Analysis of the Fish-Hook Effect in Hydrocyclone Classifiers, Chemicals Engineering Journal, 80, p. 251 (2000).

[23] Majumder, A.K., Shah, H., Shukla, P. and Barnwal, J.P., Effect of Operating Variables on Shape
of “Fish-Hook” Curves in Cyclones, Minerals Engineering, 20, p. 204 (2007).

[24] Majumder, A.K., Yerriswamy, P. and Barnwal, J.P.,  The “Fish-Hook” Phenomenon in Centrifugal Separation of Fine Particles, Minerals Engineering, 16, p. 1005 (2003).

[25] Shah,  H.,  Majumder,  A.K.,  Barnwal,  J.P.  and Shukla, P.,  “New Understanding on “Fish-Hook” Effect in Hydrocyclone”, Proceedings of MPT 2007, pp. 425-428 (2007).

[26] Lynch et al., Simulation of Closed Circuit Clinker Grinding, Zement Kalk Gibs (English Translation), 53, p. 560 (2001)

[27] Spring, R.,  NORBAL 3: Software  for  Material Balance Reconciliation, Center de Recherché Noranda, Point-Claire, Quebec (1992).