Optimal Operation of a Three-Product Dividing-Wall Column with Self-Optimizing Control Structure Design

Document Type: Research Article

Authors

Department of Chemical Engineering, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, I.R. IRAN

Abstract

This paper deals with optimal operation of a three-product Dividing-Wall Column (DWC). The main idea is to design a control structure, through a systematic procedure for plantwide control, with an objective to achieve desired product purities with the minimum use of energy. Exact local method is used to find the best controlled variables as single measurement or combination of measurements based on the idea of self-optimizing control. It concluded that it is possible to have better self-optimizing properties by controlling linear combinations of measurements than by controlling conventional individual measurements. Dynamic validation showed that the proposed control structure with the aid of low-complexity simple PI controller stabilized the plant, rejected the effect of disturbances and made DWC to produce product with desired specifications.

Keywords

Main Subjects


[1] Kiss A.A., Bildea C.S., A Control Perspective on Process Intensification in Dividing-Wall Columns, Chemical Engineering and Processing, 50: 281-292 (2011).
[2] Kaibel G., Distillation Columns with Vertical Partitions, Chemical Engineering and Technology, 10: 92-98 (1987).
[3] Petlyuk F.B., Platonov V.M., Slavinskii D.M., Thermodynamically Optimal Method for Separating Multicomponent Mixtures, International Chemical Engineering, 5:555-561 (1965).
[4] Kiss A.A., Rewagada R.R., Energy Efficient Control of a BTX Dividing-Wall Column, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 35: 2896-2904 (2011).
[5] Ho Y.C., Ward J.D., Yu C.C., Quantifying Potential Energy Savings of Divided Wall Columns Based on Degree of Remixing, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 50: 1473-1487 (2011).
[6] Ling H., Cai Z., Wu H., Wang J., Shen B., Remixing Control for Divided-Wall Columns, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 50: 12694-12705 (2011).
[7] Halvorsen I.J., Skogestad S., Energy Efficient Distillation, Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 3: 571-580 (2011).
[8] Dejanovic I., Matijasevic L.J., Olujic Z., Dividing Wall Column-A Breakthrough Towards Sustainable Distilling, Chemical Engineering and Processing, 49: 559-580 (2010).
[9] Dunnebier G., Pantelides C.C., Optimal Design of Thermally Coupled Distillation Columns, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 38: 162-176 (1999).
[10] Bravo-Bravo C., Segovia-Hernandez J.G., Gutierrez-Antonio C., Duran A.L., Bonilla-Petriciolet A., Briones-Ramırez A., Extractive Dividing Wall Column: Design and Optimization, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 49: 3672-3688 (2010).
[11] Niggemann G., Hiller C., Fieg G., Modeling and In-Depth Analysis of the Start-Up of Dividing-Wall Columns, Chemical Engineering Science, 66: 5268-5283 (2011).
[12] Wang S.J., Wong D.S.H., Controllability and Energy Efficiency of a High-Purity Divided Wall Column, Chemical Engineering Science, 62: 1010-1025 (2007).
[13] Cho Y., Kim B., Kim D., Han M., Lee M., Operation of Divided Wall Column with Vapor Sidedraw Using Profile Position Control, Journal of Process Control, 19: 932-941 (2009).
[14] Adrian T., Schoenmakers H., Boll M., Model Predictive Control of Integrated Unit Operations: Control of a Divided Wall Column, Chemical Engineering and Processing, 43: 347-355 (2004).
[15] Serra M., Perrier M., Espuna A., Puigjaner L., Analysis of Different Control Possibilities for the Divided Wall Column: Feedback Diagonal and Dynamic Matrix Control, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 25: 859-866 (2001).
[16] Wolff E.A., Skogestad S., Operation of Integrated Three-Product (Petlyuk) Distillation Columns, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 34: 2094-2103 (1995).
[17] Halvorsen I.J., Skogestad S., Optimal Operation of Petlyuk Distillation: Steady-State Behavior, Journal of Process Control, 9: 407-424 (1999).
[18] Ling H., Luyben W.L., New Control Structure for Divided-Wall Columns, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 48: 6034-6049 (2009).
[19] Ling H., Luyben W.L., Temperature Control of the BTX Divided-Wall Column, Industrial and Engineering Cchemistry Research, 49: 189-203 (2010).
[20] Ghadrdan M., Skogestad S., Halvorsen I.J., Economically Optimal Control of Kaibel Distillation Column: Fixed Boilup Rate, 8th IFAC Symposium on Advanced Control of Chemical Processes, Singapore, (2012).
 [21] Ghadrdan M., Halvorsen I.J., Skogestad S., Optimal Operation of Kaibel Distillation Columns, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 89: 1382-1391 (2011).
[22] Dwivedi D., Halvorsen I.J., Skogestad S., Control Structure Selection for Three-Product Petlyuk (Dividing-Wall) Column, Chemical Engineering and Processing, 64: 57-67 (2013).
[23] Dwivedi D., Halvorsen I.J., Skogestad S., Control Structure Selection for Four-Product Petlyuk Column, Chemical Engineering and Processing: Process Intensification, 67: 49-59 (2012).
[24] Skogestad S., Plantwide Control: the Search for the Self-Optimizing Control Structure, Journal of Process Control, 10: 487-507 (2000).
[25] Skogestad S., Postlethwait I., Multivariable Feedback Control Analysis and Design, 2nd ed., John Wiley (2005).
[26] Halvorsen I.J., Skogestad S., Morud J.C., Alstad V., Optimal Selection of Controlled Variables, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 42: 3273-3284 (2003).
[27] Alstad V., Skogestad S., Hori E.S., Optimal Measurement Combinations as Controlled Variables, Journal of Process Control, 19: 138-148 (2009).
[28] Yelchuru R., Skogestad S., Convex Formulations for Optimal Selection of Controlled Variables and Measurements Using Mixed Integer Quadratic Programming, Journal of Process Control, 22: 995-1007 (2012).
[29] Alstad V., Skogestad S., Null Space Method for Selecting Optimal Measurement Combinations as Controlled Variables, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 46: 846-853 (2007).
[30] Kariwala V., Cao Y., Janardhana S., Local Self-Optimizing Control with Average Loss Minimization, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 47: 1150-1158 (2008).
[31] Araujo A., Skogestad S., Control Structure Design for the Ammonia Synthesis Process, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 32: 2920-2932 (2008).
[32] Panahi M., Skogestad S., Selection of Controlled Variables for a Natural Gas to Liquids Process, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 51: 10179-10190 (2012).
[33] Skogestad S., Near-Optimal Operation by Self-Optimizing Control: From Process Control to Marathon Running and Business Systems, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 29: 127-137 (2004).
[34] Skogestad S., Control Structure Design for Complete Chemical Plant, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 28: 219-234 (2004).
[35] Dwivedi D., Strandberg J.P., Halvorsen I.J., Preisig H.A., Skogestad S., Active Vapor Split Control for Dividing-Wall Columns, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 51: 15176-15183 (2012).
[36] Kariwala V., Cao Y., Bidirectional Branch and Bound for Controlled Variable Selection. Part II: Exact Local Method for Self-Optimizing Control, Computers and Chemical Engineering, 33: 1402-1412 (2009).
[37] Vandiggelen R.C., Kiss A.A., Heemink A.W., Comparison of Control Strategies for Dividing-Wall Columns, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 49: 288-307 (2010).
[38] Skogestad S., Simple Analytic Rules for Model Reduction and PID Controller Tuning, Journal of Process Control, 13: 291-309 (2003).